How images like #DonDaleKids let us 'perform' our shock and outrage
His head hangs forward, enclosed in a white bag known in rough prison parlance as a "spit hood." His young chest exposed, two black straps tie his shoulders to the chair. The harrowing image of then-17-year-old Dylan Voller, taken from the ABC's investigation into the 'torture' of young people at the Don Dale Youth Detention Centre in Darwin, Australia, is just one of many instances of abuse detailed in the news program aired Monday. But it is the one that was chosen to lead a myriad news stories, and the one destined to be imprinted on the national conscience. It is the Voller image that has been most tweeted, posted and linked to in the days since the program. Is it possible that one of the reasons images like Voller's go viral is because they are a way for us to signal our innocence? To profess that we didn't know what was happening at Don Dale. We display our horror, but perhaps the reason the image means so much is because we knew all along. When we share Voller's image on social media, we are shocked but we're also pantomiming shock. Such images become iconic because they are linked to historic depictions of horror and cruelty, which we know implicitly should be disavowed publicly and social media provides the means. As many have pointed out, there is a direct line of inheritance between the picture of Voller, hooded and tied to a chair, and the image of Ali Shallal al-Qaisi, the hooded man at Abu Ghraib. Such images have the power to become an event, with their own strange weather and momentum, Suvendrini Perera, professor of cultural studies at Curtin University, told Mashable Australia. To do so, they need to tie into a broader social imagining. "I think it has to have that historical resonance, it has to link to other images that are familiar in the culture, consciously or unconsciously," she said. Such images – people tied and restrained – are part of a visual language of global terror, but there are also particular messages for Australians implicit in Voller's bound arms and legs. Aboriginal Australians are vastly overrepresented in Australian jails, and 97 percent of incarcerated youth in the Northern Territory are Indigenous. To be Australian is to inherit a catalog of images of black men and women in chains. Ann McGrath, professor of history and director of the Australian Centre for Indigenous History at the Australian National University, pointed out this link. "People instantly see this carceral history and the cruelty of people who had just been living out in the bush, [who] suddenly couldn't be any less free in these horrible restraints," she said. For photos of this nature, people don't even need to know the story to create their own, she suggested. "I think people do think of Abu Ghraib, but then they think of the Northern Territory and they know the story of stolen children," she added. "This has reminded them of that longer history of cruelty." Professor Perera agreed, but linked the images to the transnational nature of state and racial violence. "Those images that we recall of Aboriginal people being shackled and manacled, those also link to histories of slavery in the U.S," she said. "The way that colonial violence was practiced and performed on Indigenous and non-white bodies." Voller's image has gone viral because it lets us participate in a rejection of this reality, which, of course, we should have been doing all along. "Our society functions on us not knowing and not seeing, and our being constantly able to say, ‘we didn't know,’ " Perera said, "but in fact we do know. "It's almost an exaggerated horror. I understand that people aregenerally horrified, but as Tony Birch has said, the novelist and historian, it's a stain on our nation that so many people say they're shocked, or are shocked, because we should not be shocked." This performance is not reserved for civilians, however. The government is also being allowed to perform outrage over Voller's image. The tape had barely finished rolling before Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull called for a Royal Commission into juvenile detention in the Northern Territory. One can tell this is simply performance because Turnbull has so far declined to expand the commission's remit to other states, which could surely provide photos to match Voller's treatment. And because the Northern Territory government will be involved in the joint inquiry. This is the same Northern Territory government that voted for guards to be able to use mechanical restraints on children like Voller. Performance can activate real change, however. Images bear witness, but they can also translate into new movements. Take the Black Lives Matter movement in the U.S. People witnessed the video of Philando Castile dying next to his girlfriend in a live Facebook video and took their bodies to the streets in protest. "People have been taking those images to the public space and actually acting out the photographs: People doing 'hands up don't shoot,' the 'die-ins,'" Perera added. "It's part of the power of the Black Lives Matter movement that there are people keeping them alive in action. "It's really how we follow up, how we keep those images alive, how we keep those sensations alive." If not, we can only wait for the next outraging image to flood social media -- one that will remind us, dimly, of something we saw in 2016: Dylan Voller, tied to that chair. Rallies drawing attention to the incarceration and treatment of Indigenous youth in detention are currently being planned in all capital cities around Australia. See Facebook for details. Tweet may have been deleted
The historical resonance
Tweet may have been deleted
We say we don't know, but we do
Tweet may have been deleted
- 最近发表
-
- Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- 汉源县公安局交警大队:放假离校严把控 超员违法严惩处
- 380多家山东企业受益中澳自贸协定合计减让税款3.2亿元
- 灞变笢绉诲姩鎼缓鈥滅編涓戒埂鏉戔€濈患鍚堜俊鎭寲鏈嶅姟骞冲彴锛乢涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- Our galaxy might crash into Andromeda. What would happen to Earth?
- 灞变笢绉诲姩鎼缓鈥滅編涓戒埂鏉戔€濈患鍚堜俊鎭寲鏈嶅姟骞冲彴锛乢涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
- 农财月报:盘点2023,瞭望2024
- 青岛德州扒鸡公司投产 年可加工扒鸡2000万只
- 水产品占“四席”!广州南沙十个农产品上榜“国字号”
- 2016年山东抽查进口商品不合格30.6% 9批被召回
- 随机阅读
-
- Amazon Android Days sale 2024: Save on unlocked phones, tablets, and more
- 情暖人间 喜旺集团为贫困老人送温暖
- 雅安中院2篇裁判文书在全省“十佳裁判文书”评选中脱颖而出
- 雅安中院2篇裁判文书在全省“十佳裁判文书”评选中脱颖而出
- Best smart home deals this week
- 海信电器2016年全年实现营业收入318.32亿元
- 情暖人间 喜旺集团为贫困老人送温暖
- 进口化妆品新规将实施:境内收货人须申请备案
- Against All Odds: How Netflix Made It
- 汉源县公安局交警大队:放假离校严把控 超员违法严惩处
- 我市公安交警部门为第38届环城跑护航
- 借力民俗文化舞台 展现农行品牌形象
- Sinner vs. Michelsen 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
- 大学生当职业农民 11人中收入最高者年薪30万
- 红领走远 酷特来了 22岁红领集团正式更名“酷特”
- 加强个人防护,预防传染疾病
- The AI stock bubble has burst. Here's how we know.
- 瑗挎捣宀告柊鍖?016骞碐DP杩?900浜 鍏ㄥ浗鏂板尯涓夊己
- 发挥好带头人作用 带领乡亲一起致富
- 2017鎴戜滑娆箰缁х画 娼嶅潑銆佹穭鍗氫細鍛樹翰瀛愭俯鏆栭€佹儏
- 搜索
-
- 友情链接
-